"I am busy just now again on electro- magnetism,
and think I have got hold of a good thing, but can't say. It may be a weed
instead of a fish that, after all my labor, I may at last pull up."
The writer was Michael Faraday and his catch turned
out to be a very big fish indeed. Faraday's work on the relationship between
electricity and magnetism was among the most important research of the
19th century, but his writings give a unique insight into the worries facing
a scientist working at the edge of human knowledge. You could say Jordan
Maclay is in a similar position.
Last year, Maclay secured funding from NASA to study
the energy of a vacuum. His research is part of the Breakthrough Propulsion
Physics programme based at the NASA Glenn Research Center in Cleveland,
Ohio. The goal of the programme is to find new methods of propulsion that
could power spacecraft. His plan is to build a tiny machine that will measure
this vacuum energy and the forces it can produce. If things go well, Maclay
could land a fish of gargantuan proportions. He hopes to find a way of
exploiting these forces to do something useful such as drive a miniature
piston, heat water, or even power a spacecraft. Next week, he will outline
his plans at a meeting of the Space Technology and Applications International
Forum in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
Most people assume that the vacuum is empty. But according
to quantum electrodynamics, the theory that describes the behaviour of
the Universe at the very small scale, nothing could be further from the
truth. The vacuum is actually seething with electromagnetic energy called
zero-point energy and it's this that Maclay hopes to tap. The "zero" in
zero-point refers to the fact that if you were to cool the Universe to
absolute zero, its lowest possible energy state, some energy would remain.
Actually, rather a lot of energy. Physicists disagree over just how much,
but Maclay has calculated that a region of the vacuum the size of a proton
could contain as much energy as all the matter in the entire Universe.
In 1948, a Dutch physicist called Hendrick Casimir proposed
a scheme to test for the presence of this energy. In theory, vacuum energy
takes the form of particles that are constantly forming and disappearing
on a tiny scale. Normally, the vacuum is filled with particles of almost
any wavelength, but Casimir argued that if you were to place two thin uncharged
metal plates very close together, longer wavelengths would be excluded.
The extra waves outside the plates would then generate a force that tended
to push them together, and the closer the plates were together, the stronger
the attraction would be. In 1996, physicists measured the so-called Casimir
effect for the first time.
Maclay, a former professor of electrical engineering
at the University of Illinois in Chicago, wants to go further and has formed
a company called Quantum Fields in Richland Center, Wisconsin, to develop
his ideas. He and others have calculated that the Casimir effect can produce
repulsive forces as well as attractive ones. His analysis has focused not
on metal plates but on tiny metal boxes, roughly 1 micrometre or less on
each side, which he refers to as cavities(see diagram).
It turns out that
the Casimir force, and its direction, depend on the shape of the cavity.
"If you have a cavity the shape of a pizza box, the pressure on the two
large sides of the box pushes them together, but the force on the narrow
sides pushes them apart," he says.
The cavity Maclay finds most intriguing is long and
thin, like the box a tube of toothpaste comes in, and about the size of
an Escherichia coli bacterium. What's significant about this cavity
is that one of its long sides is at perfect equilibrium: the inward and
outward vacuum pressures are exactly equal. But it's a tenuous equilibrium.
And that's what makes it interesting.
Maclay plans to build a box in which the side at equilibrium--call
it the lid--is free to move. If the lid moves inward slightly from the
equilibrium point, the vacuum pressure inside the cavity goes down, and
the lid is drawn farther in. If it moves outward the reverse happens and
the lid is pushed away. The distances involved are tiny--less than 100
nanometres. The lid will be attached to a microscopic spring. So when the
lid moves, the spring will be stretched or compressed and will tend to
return to its original position. Maclay is hoping that by carefully balancing
the vacuum pressure of the cavity and the elasticity of the spring, and
by giving the lid just the right initial impulse, he can create a tiny
oscillator driven by Casimir forces.
That's the ideal scenario, at any rate. But it's easy
to make things look good on paper. "From a theoretical viewpoint," says
Maclay, "all kinds of things oscillate. But in the real world? Well, that's
what we have to look at."
Maclay plans to attack the problem in stages. Repulsive
Casimir forces have never been measured so his first task will be to find
out if he can even do this. Next he'll measure the inward and outward forces
at the surfaces of cavities with different shapes, to see if they match
predictions. And if all that goes well, he'll be ready to build a resonating
cavity.
The job of building the experimental setup falls to
Rod Clark, a former nuclear engineer and president of MEMS Optical, a technology
company based in Huntsville, Alabama, that manufactures microelectromechanical
devices (MEMs). To build Maclay's cavities out of silicon, Clark hopes
to use a combination of traditional lithographic etching and deposition
techniques--the same techniques used to make integrated circuits.
Clark is confident that he can produce the necessary
structures. But he's also well aware of the challenges, the first of which
is size. Maclay's specifications are at the limits of today's fabrication
technology, says Clark. "We want to make it small in order to make the
forces large. But we can't make it so small that we can't fabricate it."
Maclay and Clark's current plan is to make an array
of hundreds of topless cavities on a substrate, and then create a single
lid that fits over the entire array. The lid will be suspended on springs
above the array, which will be moved toward the lid in tiny steps. Initially
the lid should remain still, but when the cavities get close enough, the
difference in vacuum pressure should cause it to move and possibly even
to oscillate. By peering across the surface of the lid through a microscope,
it will be possible to measure its displacement with great precision.
Neither Maclay nor Clark expects quick results. Over
the course of the three-year period covered by NASA's grant, they hope
to build three generations of devices.
Still, Maclay is already dreaming of various types of
"Casimir machines" that might be possible if his experiments prove successful.
Microscopic vacuum-drive levers, pulleys and pistons come to mind, for
example. Or perhaps a machine that contains cavities that generate different
vacuum pressures and exploits that difference in much the same way that
a heat engine exploits differences in temperature. "What we're looking
at now are very simple things that ultimately will serve as components
of more complicated systems," he says. "We've gotta kind of mess around
to see what they can do."
How does Maclay rate his chances of success? "If I thought
the chance was zero," he says, "I wouldn't spend my time on it. I'm convinced
we'll find some interesting things. Exactly what and what its utility will
be, I don't know."
Marc Millis, who heads NASA's Breakthrough Propulsion
Physics programme, is also philosophical about the prospects. He'd be thrilled,
of course, if Maclay handed him the keys to an interstellar propulsion
drive. "I would be very surprised if there wasn't a potential breakthrough
of some kind," he says of the entire propulsion project. If Maclay is able
to reel in his fish, he could have a phenomenon to rival Faraday's in importance.
And as Faraday once said: "Nothing is too wonderful to be true if it be
consistent with the laws of nature."